An article recently asked this question based on the observation that fewer than 10% of UK professors are female. The problem posed is the familiar one of retention of women in science after graduation, rather than engagement of girls at earlier stages. Statistics quoted for the UK are similar to those in the US: around half of science students are female (even higher for biology). So, there seems to be less of a problem attracting young females to science. After graduation, however, the numbers shrink as women, facing the realities of balancing a career in a highly competitive field with family obligations and other interests, begin to drop out. The article goes on to discuss what might be done to help women stay in science.
Viewing women in science as endangered is an interesting way to look for solutions. Using the endangered species model as a guide, we can immediately focus on the habitat as a critical factor in species survival. Just as an endangered plant or animal requires certain environmental conditions to maintain a healthy population, women in science also require a supportive environment to not only survive, but to thrive. For example: sufficient resources and space (habitat) as well as ways to support recruitment and minimize losses are necessary to have a viable population. From an individual's standpoint, it means everything one needs to compete with others successfully. It's not a perfect analogy, but perhaps useful to ponder how one's work environment, especially support from superiors, staff, and colleagues, can be a major factor in whether a woman chooses to remain in her career or drop out.
Just the other day, I was talking with another member of a Women in Science group at a university where I am an adjunct. I've been attending the meetings of this group off and on for over a year and providing some insights about being a woman in science, basically saying that there will be bumps in the road, but it gets better if you stick it out. One or two other senior female faculty had also been attending and providing the same type of message, in various ways. This was not a planned strategy on our part...it just came across that way.
I had been wondering if the students and postdocs who belonged to this group were getting anything out of our meetings (I had never really gotten any direct feedback from them, positive or negative). Anyway, she had been talking to one of the students who belonged to the group and who had told her that these meetings had greatly influenced her. The student had been having some problems and was thinking that she was not cut out for a career in science. Hearing from some senior female scientists and seeing how we had succeeded convinced her to persevere. It seemed that hearing stories about what issues we had faced and how we dealt with them essentially sent the message that they were not alone in their experience, i.e., it was normal to occasionally feel inadequate or uncertain about a science career, but it would pass.
It's important to have a support group, whether you are having problems or not. Perhaps you are supremely confident in your capabilities and are sailing through your graduate program or postdoc training. However, you never know what might change tomorrow to throw a wrench into your plans. I find that those students who have rarely (or never) faced real difficulties are the least prepared to deal with a major setback. They are so accustomed to things always going their way, that they are left confused and shaken when things go wrong. Instead, those who have had to work hard expect difficulties and usually have developed good coping mechanisms and especially a support network.
Having a support group can be a life saver in such instances. I didn't, and struggled to maintain my confidence and to see my way forward when those obstacles occurred. Even my spouse (a science professor), who provided emotional support, really didn't understand from his perspective as a male in a male-dominated field. Consequently, much of his encouragement missed the mark. He really could not grasp what it is like to be marginalized or even actively discouraged by superiors and coworkers. He was always accepted as rightfully belonging to the science club, assumed to be competent (or had the potential), expected to be ambitious and to advance up the career ladder. He's never really understood what it was like not to have that kind of underpinning.
I'm convinced that it takes someone who has had similar experiences to provide you with the right kind of support or encouragement. Peers (male or female), who are not experiencing problems, may even be dismissive or critical of you, believing that the fault lies in your inability to deal with everyday issues (or even that your behavior is the source of the problem). This attitude, whether voiced or not, can be extremely damaging...perhaps more so than the problem itself.
Anyone who is facing a problem, especially one that shakes an individual's confidence, needs reassurance that they can overcome it. Yes, in some cases, the victim is part of the problem and needs to do some serious reassessment of their interpersonal dealings. But the way to help them (if you are their friend) is to assure them that others have had this same problem, but succeeded in dealing with it....by doing x, y, or z. Hearing a true story from someone who lived through it is a safe way to get the message across without blatantly blaming the victim, which will only make them more defensive.
In recounting such a story, a veteran might say, "I didn't realize initially how I was viewed by colleagues, but once I did, it seemed obvious that they would continue treating me badly as long as I continued my behavior. I finally realized that they had no incentive to change, but I did. Once I modified how I (fill in the blank), their attitude toward me began to change."
Stories are excellent ways to teach others. They convey real (or sometimes imagined) situations and describe how the heroine overcomes obstacles and goes on to a successful career in science. Perhaps we need more of such stories, including the emotional and gritty details, to help prepare those starting out to expect and conquer impediments....and eventually, women in science will be taken off the endangered species list.
Showing posts with label confidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label confidence. Show all posts
Sunday, August 7, 2011
Friday, May 20, 2011
Lie to Me
In the previous post, I posed a hypothetical situation in which a post-doc, Jim, suffers from overconfidence in his abilities, and despite Jim's obvious deficiencies, the lab director thinks he's a valuable contributor to the research project you lead.
If you've read previous posts, you will recognize that Jim (and possibly the lab director) suffer from the Dunning-Kruger effect. People with this condition are unskilled and incapable of accurately assessing their abilities as well as those of others. The reason is that the skills required to be competent are often the same skills required to evaluate that competence. They tend to greatly overinflate their performances relative to those of others. The more ignorant they are, the greater their confidence in themselves.
In the hypothetical situation described above, the project leader is caught between a rock (Jim) and a hard place (lab director). You have laid out Jim's deficiencies, backed up with ample data, for both Jim and the director...only to have both of them ignore your logical argument and restate their illogical position about Jim's competence. Their reaction is due to their overall inability to make logical judgments and to recognize that they have this problem.....a vicious cycle that is difficult to break. The more logic you throw at them, the more firmly they adhere to their mistaken opinion and confidence in that decision.
Most of us in science are pretty logical people; so when confronted with such illogical behavior, we go a little nuts. We simply cannot understand how someone can totally ignore the evidence in front of them. We make the mistake of thinking that if we just produce enough evidence or a clear-enough argument, that we'll prevail. However, that is not going to happen with people like this. Think about religious zealots or climate deniers....nothing you say is going to change their minds. You have to approach such people with a clear understanding of their psychology, not based on your preconceived notions that everyone is as logical as you are.
What does work? Research has shown that training, for example in social reasoning, helps improve Dunning-Kruger folks' cognitive abilities. How does that help you, as a project leader? You're not a psychologist; nor do you have time to be training someone who should already have skills in logic. Quite a conundrum. I don't think there is a really good solution to this situation.
If I had control over this person's position, i.e., was Jim's supervisor, I would place him on probation and clearly outline what outcomes are expected for all tasks, set deadlines for those outcomes, and spell out the consequences of failure. The plan would be detailed in such a way as to leave no wiggle-room for Jim to blame external factors, if he fails. Both of us must sign this performance plan, acknowledging our understanding of what's expected and the consequences. If he protests, I would reply that since he is so confident in his abilities, he should have no problem meeting these basic expectations (which I have set up for all others on the team). If Jim manages to improve and meets his responsibilities, then things will have been improved for the team, and everyone wins. If Jim fails, then I have documentation to take steps to dismiss him; but I won't feel badly because I've been totally fair and upfront with him.
However, in the hypothetical situation posed, I would not have control over Jim's position, and I also have to deal with the director who suffers from the same cognitive deficit as Jim. In this situation, I would want to get Jim off my team so that his performance no longer harmed me or others. Here is one possible tactic: I would suggest to Jim that he should have his own project to run and that he should run the idea by the director. I would support Jim's proposal when the director asks my opinion. Convincing the director should not be difficult, given his lack of logic skills and being Jim's biggest fan.
The key will be to have Jim report directly to the director rather than to me. If the director tries to make me oversee Jim's project, I have two possible responses: 1) I cannot be in charge of Jim's performance unless I'm made his official supervisor (in which case, I can put the previous plan in motion), 2) I state that I have my hands full leading my own project and cannot be expected to handle a second project, and/or 3) I remind him that making me responsible for Jim's project defeats the purpose of giving Jim his own project. Hopefully, this would not be too much logic for the director to handle.
Assuming I can pull this off, I will no longer have Jim on my team. Even if this means more work for the team...well, we already were having to redo his work. And the director will eventually see for himself Jim's incompetency. If not, then I might want to start looking for another job--because the director is probably not judging my performance well either.
Some might feel that the above plan is unfair or underhanded. Actually, this problem with Jim is due entirely to Jim's incompetence and to the director's failure to deal with it. The two people responsible for the problems the research project is experiencing (mistakes, slow progress, low morale) should have to deal with them, not me and not the other productive team members. The latter situation is what is unfair. My plan takes the false beliefs of Jim and the director and forces the two of them to deal with the consequences.
So to summarize how to deal with someone suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect:
1. Don't make the mistake of assuming they think like you do. Trying to use logic doesn't work because they do not think logically.
2. Focus on their overinflated beliefs and take advantage of them in formulating your strategy.
3. Don't cover for them when their incompetency causes problems.
4. Find a way to make them responsible for the consequences of their incompetency.
Image Credit: Jon Wilkins 2011; Creative Commons; http://www.darwineatscake.com
If you've read previous posts, you will recognize that Jim (and possibly the lab director) suffer from the Dunning-Kruger effect. People with this condition are unskilled and incapable of accurately assessing their abilities as well as those of others. The reason is that the skills required to be competent are often the same skills required to evaluate that competence. They tend to greatly overinflate their performances relative to those of others. The more ignorant they are, the greater their confidence in themselves.
In the hypothetical situation described above, the project leader is caught between a rock (Jim) and a hard place (lab director). You have laid out Jim's deficiencies, backed up with ample data, for both Jim and the director...only to have both of them ignore your logical argument and restate their illogical position about Jim's competence. Their reaction is due to their overall inability to make logical judgments and to recognize that they have this problem.....a vicious cycle that is difficult to break. The more logic you throw at them, the more firmly they adhere to their mistaken opinion and confidence in that decision.
Most of us in science are pretty logical people; so when confronted with such illogical behavior, we go a little nuts. We simply cannot understand how someone can totally ignore the evidence in front of them. We make the mistake of thinking that if we just produce enough evidence or a clear-enough argument, that we'll prevail. However, that is not going to happen with people like this. Think about religious zealots or climate deniers....nothing you say is going to change their minds. You have to approach such people with a clear understanding of their psychology, not based on your preconceived notions that everyone is as logical as you are.
What does work? Research has shown that training, for example in social reasoning, helps improve Dunning-Kruger folks' cognitive abilities. How does that help you, as a project leader? You're not a psychologist; nor do you have time to be training someone who should already have skills in logic. Quite a conundrum. I don't think there is a really good solution to this situation.
If I had control over this person's position, i.e., was Jim's supervisor, I would place him on probation and clearly outline what outcomes are expected for all tasks, set deadlines for those outcomes, and spell out the consequences of failure. The plan would be detailed in such a way as to leave no wiggle-room for Jim to blame external factors, if he fails. Both of us must sign this performance plan, acknowledging our understanding of what's expected and the consequences. If he protests, I would reply that since he is so confident in his abilities, he should have no problem meeting these basic expectations (which I have set up for all others on the team). If Jim manages to improve and meets his responsibilities, then things will have been improved for the team, and everyone wins. If Jim fails, then I have documentation to take steps to dismiss him; but I won't feel badly because I've been totally fair and upfront with him.
However, in the hypothetical situation posed, I would not have control over Jim's position, and I also have to deal with the director who suffers from the same cognitive deficit as Jim. In this situation, I would want to get Jim off my team so that his performance no longer harmed me or others. Here is one possible tactic: I would suggest to Jim that he should have his own project to run and that he should run the idea by the director. I would support Jim's proposal when the director asks my opinion. Convincing the director should not be difficult, given his lack of logic skills and being Jim's biggest fan.
The key will be to have Jim report directly to the director rather than to me. If the director tries to make me oversee Jim's project, I have two possible responses: 1) I cannot be in charge of Jim's performance unless I'm made his official supervisor (in which case, I can put the previous plan in motion), 2) I state that I have my hands full leading my own project and cannot be expected to handle a second project, and/or 3) I remind him that making me responsible for Jim's project defeats the purpose of giving Jim his own project. Hopefully, this would not be too much logic for the director to handle.
Assuming I can pull this off, I will no longer have Jim on my team. Even if this means more work for the team...well, we already were having to redo his work. And the director will eventually see for himself Jim's incompetency. If not, then I might want to start looking for another job--because the director is probably not judging my performance well either.
Some might feel that the above plan is unfair or underhanded. Actually, this problem with Jim is due entirely to Jim's incompetence and to the director's failure to deal with it. The two people responsible for the problems the research project is experiencing (mistakes, slow progress, low morale) should have to deal with them, not me and not the other productive team members. The latter situation is what is unfair. My plan takes the false beliefs of Jim and the director and forces the two of them to deal with the consequences.
So to summarize how to deal with someone suffering from the Dunning-Kruger effect:
1. Don't make the mistake of assuming they think like you do. Trying to use logic doesn't work because they do not think logically.
2. Focus on their overinflated beliefs and take advantage of them in formulating your strategy.
3. Don't cover for them when their incompetency causes problems.
4. Find a way to make them responsible for the consequences of their incompetency.
Image Credit: Jon Wilkins 2011; Creative Commons; http://www.darwineatscake.com
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Lost in Translation
What would you do if faced with the following situation?
You are part of a research team that is involved in a large project. One of the team members, a post-doc, is very enthusiastic and outgoing. Jim exudes confidence in his abilities and contributions to the project. Unfortunately, Jim is a total disaster in the lab, and his writing is abysmal. Worse, he is blissfully unaware of his incompetence, despite repeatedly being shown his mistakes. As project leader, it falls upon you to clean up Jim's mistakes, reassign work (that has been compromised) to other team members, and revise his reports. Jim's manuscripts have to be completely rewritten from scratch, but he still expects to be listed as first author and behaves as if the revised version is his work. The other team members have become resentful of Jim and complain to you often.
You cannot replace Jim because you do not have the authority; only the lab director can dismiss someone. The lab director is totally enamored with Jim, whose overconfident behavior has convinced the director that he is one of the most valuable members of the research team. The director is also a person who lacks the metacognitive skills (or time) to accurately assess Jim's real competency. You have tried to convince the director that Jim's performance is substandard and is hurting the group's progress, but he remains adamant in his confidence that Jim is competent. The director believes Jim has just made a couple of mistakes, which could happen to anyone.
What would you do? See the next post for how I would respond. In the meantime, take a look at the video below for a nice explanation of the Dunning-Kruger effect...and see if it suggests any solutions.
You are part of a research team that is involved in a large project. One of the team members, a post-doc, is very enthusiastic and outgoing. Jim exudes confidence in his abilities and contributions to the project. Unfortunately, Jim is a total disaster in the lab, and his writing is abysmal. Worse, he is blissfully unaware of his incompetence, despite repeatedly being shown his mistakes. As project leader, it falls upon you to clean up Jim's mistakes, reassign work (that has been compromised) to other team members, and revise his reports. Jim's manuscripts have to be completely rewritten from scratch, but he still expects to be listed as first author and behaves as if the revised version is his work. The other team members have become resentful of Jim and complain to you often.
You cannot replace Jim because you do not have the authority; only the lab director can dismiss someone. The lab director is totally enamored with Jim, whose overconfident behavior has convinced the director that he is one of the most valuable members of the research team. The director is also a person who lacks the metacognitive skills (or time) to accurately assess Jim's real competency. You have tried to convince the director that Jim's performance is substandard and is hurting the group's progress, but he remains adamant in his confidence that Jim is competent. The director believes Jim has just made a couple of mistakes, which could happen to anyone.
What would you do? See the next post for how I would respond. In the meantime, take a look at the video below for a nice explanation of the Dunning-Kruger effect...and see if it suggests any solutions.
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Beyond the Imposter Syndrome
I came across a blog post at "On Becoming a Domestic and Laboratory Goddess" in which the blogger, Isis, announces that the "imposter syndrome" is a scam. In case you've not heard of it, this condition is one in which the person secretly feels like an imposter in their field, despite being highly competent and successful. They are afraid that eventually everyone will find out that they are not a real scientist. Graduate students (in general) and women in STEM fields seem to suffer disproportionately from this problem.
Anyway, Isis expresses frustration over how many women are moaning about suffering from this condition. I think the concern here is that women will attribute any failure (to land a grant, to publish a paper) to this syndrome and this behavior will, consequently, enhance the belief that they are imposters. I also suspect that those who have read or written a lot about the imposter syndrome have become weary of it and think that there is nothing new to be learned.
However, I think there is more to be understood about imposter syndrome and its opposite, the Dunning-Kruger effect, which I think of as the "overinflated ego syndrome". The Dunning-Kruger effect is one in which the person overestimates their abilities...and the more incompetent they are, the higher their level of confidence in their abilities. At first glance, it seems incomprehensible that people who constantly make mistakes or fail to meet performance expectations would paradoxically believe that they are competent or skilled. However, the mental skills required to be competent at any task (e.g., ability to assess what steps to take to accomplish the task, to gauge standards of performance) are the same skills needed to accurately evaluate one's own competence.
Kruger and Dunning summarize the key features of such people:
Thus, people who are generally incompetent are unable to gauge their own performance correctly and tend to over-inflate their performance (in their minds) relative to the performance of others. Ehrlinger et al. provide the following example:
"..to produce a grammatically correct sentence, one must know something about the rules of grammar. But one must also have an adequate knowledge of the rules of grammar in order to recognize when a sentence is grammatically correct, whether written by one's self or by another person. Thus, those who lack grammatical expertise are not in a position to accurately judge the quality of their attempts or the attempts of other people. In addition, because people tend to choose the responses they think are most reasonable, people with deficits are likely to believe they are doing quite well even when they are, in reality, doing quite poorly."
Sufferers of the imposter syndrome are just the opposite. In psychological terms, imposter syndrome is a condition in which the sufferer is not able to internalize his or her accomplishments and skills. They are highly critical of themselves and tend to over-inflate the performance of those around them. If we use graduate students as an example, we can see the dynamics involved in creating the imposter mindset. Students are in a subordinate position from virtually every standpoint. They interact with people who are obviously competent and superior (professors) and who constantly tell the student (in various ways) that they are not yet competent at the skills required to succeed in their field of study. When the student is thrust into a position of responsibility (they graduate and get a job), they may find it difficult to transition from the "incompetent" to the "totally competent" mindset. They may go on to develop "imposter syndrome".
These two syndromes are neatly summarized in one of my favorite sayings: "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge." Charles Darwin.
Of course, these are two extremes along a wide spectrum of mental states. Most of us fall somewhere in the middle, perhaps with more women toward the imposter end and more men toward the inflated ego end (I have no data, just more than 40 years of observations). We may shift between these mental states over time, depending on our history and new situations. I recall feeling like an imposter right after attaining my Ph.D., but this faded with time and experience. I can envision someone taking on a job in a new field and initially feeling like an imposter...at least until some experience in the new position is gained. You can probably think of many other examples.
So what does all this have to do with women in science and does this information lead to any insights as to how we may solve some of the "challenges" we face? More in the next post.
Anyway, Isis expresses frustration over how many women are moaning about suffering from this condition. I think the concern here is that women will attribute any failure (to land a grant, to publish a paper) to this syndrome and this behavior will, consequently, enhance the belief that they are imposters. I also suspect that those who have read or written a lot about the imposter syndrome have become weary of it and think that there is nothing new to be learned.
However, I think there is more to be understood about imposter syndrome and its opposite, the Dunning-Kruger effect, which I think of as the "overinflated ego syndrome". The Dunning-Kruger effect is one in which the person overestimates their abilities...and the more incompetent they are, the higher their level of confidence in their abilities. At first glance, it seems incomprehensible that people who constantly make mistakes or fail to meet performance expectations would paradoxically believe that they are competent or skilled. However, the mental skills required to be competent at any task (e.g., ability to assess what steps to take to accomplish the task, to gauge standards of performance) are the same skills needed to accurately evaluate one's own competence.
Kruger and Dunning summarize the key features of such people:
- They tend to overestimate their own level of skill;
- They fail to recognize genuine skill in others;
- They fail to recognize the extremity of their inadequacy
Thus, people who are generally incompetent are unable to gauge their own performance correctly and tend to over-inflate their performance (in their minds) relative to the performance of others. Ehrlinger et al. provide the following example:
"..to produce a grammatically correct sentence, one must know something about the rules of grammar. But one must also have an adequate knowledge of the rules of grammar in order to recognize when a sentence is grammatically correct, whether written by one's self or by another person. Thus, those who lack grammatical expertise are not in a position to accurately judge the quality of their attempts or the attempts of other people. In addition, because people tend to choose the responses they think are most reasonable, people with deficits are likely to believe they are doing quite well even when they are, in reality, doing quite poorly."
Sufferers of the imposter syndrome are just the opposite. In psychological terms, imposter syndrome is a condition in which the sufferer is not able to internalize his or her accomplishments and skills. They are highly critical of themselves and tend to over-inflate the performance of those around them. If we use graduate students as an example, we can see the dynamics involved in creating the imposter mindset. Students are in a subordinate position from virtually every standpoint. They interact with people who are obviously competent and superior (professors) and who constantly tell the student (in various ways) that they are not yet competent at the skills required to succeed in their field of study. When the student is thrust into a position of responsibility (they graduate and get a job), they may find it difficult to transition from the "incompetent" to the "totally competent" mindset. They may go on to develop "imposter syndrome".
These two syndromes are neatly summarized in one of my favorite sayings: "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge." Charles Darwin.
Of course, these are two extremes along a wide spectrum of mental states. Most of us fall somewhere in the middle, perhaps with more women toward the imposter end and more men toward the inflated ego end (I have no data, just more than 40 years of observations). We may shift between these mental states over time, depending on our history and new situations. I recall feeling like an imposter right after attaining my Ph.D., but this faded with time and experience. I can envision someone taking on a job in a new field and initially feeling like an imposter...at least until some experience in the new position is gained. You can probably think of many other examples.
So what does all this have to do with women in science and does this information lead to any insights as to how we may solve some of the "challenges" we face? More in the next post.
Labels:
confidence,
criticism,
handling criticism,
mindset,
perfectionism
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
Why Being Good at Art Is Important to Me as a Scientist
I previously described a study that found female students who participated in a writing exercise (to reflect about their most cherished values) performed better in a physics class. I thought it might be worthwhile to show the full set of choices presented to the students. Glancing at the list, I made my selection of the top three with little hesitation. I then went on to write down why these values were important to me. It definitely makes you think about what is really important and why. The exercise also gives you an idea of what you might want to focus upon in the event you suffer some setback or are feeling down about yourself.
Here are the twelve values presented to the students in the writing exercise:
1. being good at art
2. creativity
3. relationships with family & friends
4. government or politics
5. independence
6. learning and gaining knowledge
7. athletic ability
8. belonging to a social group (community, racial, school club)
9. music
10. career
11. spiritual or religious values
12. sense of humor
The investigators avoided values that dealt with science and math. The students were instructed to circle the two or three values that were most important to them. Students in the control group were asked to circle the two or three least important values. Then they were asked to describe in a few sentences either why the selected values were important to them or why they might be important to someone else (controls). They were later asked to look at the values they selected and list the top two reasons why they were important. The final part of the exercise reinforced the choices by asking the student to rate their agreement with statements about the selected values (e.g., “in general, I try to live up to these values”).
This is a sufficiently broad list that most people would have no trouble finding three items that they think are important to them (or to others in the control group) as well as choices that would likely not be important. Which three would you select and why?
One of my choices was being good at art (hence the title of this post). Answering the question of why my choices are important was a bit more difficult, but very interesting. The reasons for my selections are personal and not really of interest to anyone else--so I will say no more about my choices. What is important are your selections and why they are important to you. This writing exercise is a way to bolster one’s resilience—the ability to bounce back from adversity. It’s not so much the specific writing exercise, but the fact that it forces you to recognize what you value most about yourself and reinforces your overall sense of self-worth.
I think that leaving science or math-related attributes off the list is critical to the success of this exercise. We might make the mistake of dwelling on the science or math skill (that we feel is a weakness) and magnifying it out of proportion to reality. This reaction is human nature, and especially likely for women, e.g., what’s wrong with me that I can’t finish this project, get this paper accepted, get along with my adviser, etc.? Having non-science capabilities or sources of support (family, religion) are powerful antidotes to career setbacks. However, one first must be aware of what those values are and why they are important to us. Identification is the first step. It’s also important to actually write down our thoughts. As I’ve talked about previously, the act of writing stimulates parts of our brains that are not otherwise tapped by just “thinking” about a topic. Writing down our values and reasons also serves to solidify our confidence in those values.
As I noted in the previous post, this writing exercise is like cognitive therapy, where the patient is taught to examine dysfunctional thoughts and replace them with more positive ones. People who are subjected to frequent scrutiny and harsh criticism can develop a distorted view of themselves. Everything we do as scientists is scrutinized and assessed—by our peers, by advisors, by supervisors, by funding agencies. We are told to develop a thick skin, which may work well for men who generally tend to externalize such criticism (“What’s wrong with that reviewer—my work is superb!”). That approach may not work so well for women who tend to internalize criticism and failure (“What’s wrong with me?”).
We can begin to see why this simple writing exercise might have such a powerful effect on women, but not men. Instead of trying to emulate men (by externalizing), we might do better by re-balancing our self-image. By placing the momentary criticism or problem within the overall context of our entire lives and skill-set, we can see how those professional setbacks are not as momentous as we think.
This insight is also helpful because it shows how important it is to develop values, talents, and resources outside of our science career.
One of my choices was being good at art (hence the title of this post). Answering the question of why my choices are important was a bit more difficult, but very interesting. The reasons for my selections are personal and not really of interest to anyone else--so I will say no more about my choices. What is important are your selections and why they are important to you. This writing exercise is a way to bolster one’s resilience—the ability to bounce back from adversity. It’s not so much the specific writing exercise, but the fact that it forces you to recognize what you value most about yourself and reinforces your overall sense of self-worth.
I think that leaving science or math-related attributes off the list is critical to the success of this exercise. We might make the mistake of dwelling on the science or math skill (that we feel is a weakness) and magnifying it out of proportion to reality. This reaction is human nature, and especially likely for women, e.g., what’s wrong with me that I can’t finish this project, get this paper accepted, get along with my adviser, etc.? Having non-science capabilities or sources of support (family, religion) are powerful antidotes to career setbacks. However, one first must be aware of what those values are and why they are important to us. Identification is the first step. It’s also important to actually write down our thoughts. As I’ve talked about previously, the act of writing stimulates parts of our brains that are not otherwise tapped by just “thinking” about a topic. Writing down our values and reasons also serves to solidify our confidence in those values.
As I noted in the previous post, this writing exercise is like cognitive therapy, where the patient is taught to examine dysfunctional thoughts and replace them with more positive ones. People who are subjected to frequent scrutiny and harsh criticism can develop a distorted view of themselves. Everything we do as scientists is scrutinized and assessed—by our peers, by advisors, by supervisors, by funding agencies. We are told to develop a thick skin, which may work well for men who generally tend to externalize such criticism (“What’s wrong with that reviewer—my work is superb!”). That approach may not work so well for women who tend to internalize criticism and failure (“What’s wrong with me?”).
We can begin to see why this simple writing exercise might have such a powerful effect on women, but not men. Instead of trying to emulate men (by externalizing), we might do better by re-balancing our self-image. By placing the momentary criticism or problem within the overall context of our entire lives and skill-set, we can see how those professional setbacks are not as momentous as we think.
This insight is also helpful because it shows how important it is to develop values, talents, and resources outside of our science career.
Tuesday, December 7, 2010
Plugging the Leaky Pipeline
A recent study suggests that a simple writing exercise can bolster the confidence of female students taking a difficult science course. Social scientists, led by Akira Miyaki, found that female students who wrote an essay about their positive attributes performed better in an introductory physics class. The broader implication of the work is that plugging the leaky pipeline may only require an intervention that enhances self-worth of women in STEM fields. A detailed description of the study and its findings can be read here.
Briefly, the students (286 men and 116 women) were randomly assigned to one of two groups: those who were asked to write about (1) personal values such as relationships with friends and family or the importance of learning (they selected 3 values from a list of 10) and (2) values that were least important to them, but that might help others (control group). The results indicated that the women who wrote about values important to them did significantly better in the class than the control group; there was no difference for the males.
I was interested in why such a simple exercise could have such an effect. Although the researchers did not experimentally determine the "why", they speculated that it had something to do with ameliorating what they termed, "stereotype threat", i.e., the negative effect of the belief that women are less capable than men at science, particularly fields like physics, math, and engineering. They hypothesized that the values-affirming exercise took the women's minds off the stereotype. Can that be true?
I doubt that "taking their minds off the fact that women are inferior in science" is the explanation. However, it clearly affected something. An alternative explanation is that the writing exercise, which took place at the beginning of the class, initiated a self-affirming chain of thinking (or short-circuited a negative chain). Other studies have shown that women are particularly sensitive to set-backs, and a single negative event (criticism, poor grade on an exam) can trigger a cascade of failures as each one lowers the woman's confidence in her abilities. Women internalize (it must have been my fault), whereas men externalize (it's the other guy who's wrong). When this self-blaming is combined with other negative thinking (e.g., magnifying problems out of proportion to reality), women ultimately come to believe they are unsuited to science. If minor setbacks tend to undermine your confidence, then being forced to ponder your positive attributes and capabilities might act as an inoculation against negative thoughts (or self-blame). Challenging negative or dysfunctional thinking is a well-known psychological practice--cognitive therapy.
Regardless of the validity or purported novelty of this study's findings, I think it holds an important lesson for women in science.
Negative thinking potentially can have a really destructive effect on us--perhaps more so than for men. I see this negative behavior in a lot of blogs written by young women in science. I'm not saying it's bad to talk about the stuff that happens to us---just that it's important to put things into perspective and perhaps go an extra step to affirm our ability to deal with negative events and people. If a short-term writing exercise can have such a dramatic effect on women in a physics course, imagine what daily or weekly blogging might be doing? Are you dwelling on the negative, especially ranting about being powerless to change your fate? Or are you mostly affirming your strengths and overall resistance to negative events?
By focusing on our capabilities and accomplishments (at least the majority of the time), we might change our overall outlook and self-confidence. We might also have a positive influence on readers who are trying to decide whether to go into science or to stay in science. Wouldn't you rather read about someone who figured out how to overcome an obstacle, rather than how they were so crushed that they decided to leave science altogether?
Image Credit: modified image based on "The Scream" by Edvard Munch (1893)
Briefly, the students (286 men and 116 women) were randomly assigned to one of two groups: those who were asked to write about (1) personal values such as relationships with friends and family or the importance of learning (they selected 3 values from a list of 10) and (2) values that were least important to them, but that might help others (control group). The results indicated that the women who wrote about values important to them did significantly better in the class than the control group; there was no difference for the males.
I was interested in why such a simple exercise could have such an effect. Although the researchers did not experimentally determine the "why", they speculated that it had something to do with ameliorating what they termed, "stereotype threat", i.e., the negative effect of the belief that women are less capable than men at science, particularly fields like physics, math, and engineering. They hypothesized that the values-affirming exercise took the women's minds off the stereotype. Can that be true?
I doubt that "taking their minds off the fact that women are inferior in science" is the explanation. However, it clearly affected something. An alternative explanation is that the writing exercise, which took place at the beginning of the class, initiated a self-affirming chain of thinking (or short-circuited a negative chain). Other studies have shown that women are particularly sensitive to set-backs, and a single negative event (criticism, poor grade on an exam) can trigger a cascade of failures as each one lowers the woman's confidence in her abilities. Women internalize (it must have been my fault), whereas men externalize (it's the other guy who's wrong). When this self-blaming is combined with other negative thinking (e.g., magnifying problems out of proportion to reality), women ultimately come to believe they are unsuited to science. If minor setbacks tend to undermine your confidence, then being forced to ponder your positive attributes and capabilities might act as an inoculation against negative thoughts (or self-blame). Challenging negative or dysfunctional thinking is a well-known psychological practice--cognitive therapy.
Regardless of the validity or purported novelty of this study's findings, I think it holds an important lesson for women in science.
Negative thinking potentially can have a really destructive effect on us--perhaps more so than for men. I see this negative behavior in a lot of blogs written by young women in science. I'm not saying it's bad to talk about the stuff that happens to us---just that it's important to put things into perspective and perhaps go an extra step to affirm our ability to deal with negative events and people. If a short-term writing exercise can have such a dramatic effect on women in a physics course, imagine what daily or weekly blogging might be doing? Are you dwelling on the negative, especially ranting about being powerless to change your fate? Or are you mostly affirming your strengths and overall resistance to negative events?
By focusing on our capabilities and accomplishments (at least the majority of the time), we might change our overall outlook and self-confidence. We might also have a positive influence on readers who are trying to decide whether to go into science or to stay in science. Wouldn't you rather read about someone who figured out how to overcome an obstacle, rather than how they were so crushed that they decided to leave science altogether?
Image Credit: modified image based on "The Scream" by Edvard Munch (1893)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




